Skip to main content

Quality Scoring

Every asset submitted to NCRB receives a programmatic quality score computed off-chain by the Oracle API and then stored on-chain via QualityAssessment. The score drives the asset's rating band, which in turn informs pricing on the marketplace.


Overview​

The scoring system is designed to be:

  • Consistent — same framework across all 10 asset types
  • Aligned with industry standards — benchmarked against Sylvera, BeZero, ICVCM, and equivalent methodologies per asset class
  • Transparent — all dimension weights and band thresholds are readable on-chain via GET /api/quality-profiles/:assetType
  • Institutional-grade — mapping directly to rating conventions (AAA → Not Eligible) familiar to ESG procurement teams

Scoring Dimensions​

Every asset type uses the same six dimensions, though the specific criteria within each dimension vary by asset class:

DimensionWeightWhat It Measures
Technical Quality25%Asset-specific quality bands (Sylvera ratings, USDA land classes, ore grades, FSC certification, distinctiveness level)
Additionality20%Evidence that the environmental benefit would not have occurred without the project (financial additionality, regulatory surplus)
Permanence20%Long-term durability of the environmental benefit — reversibility risk, guarantee mechanisms, covenant length (100+ years preferred)
Certification Level15%Rigour of the issuing registry and whether the asset has CCP-Approved or equivalent status
Social Impact12%Co-benefit certifications: CCB Gold, SDG alignment, Indigenous engagement, community employment
Vintage / Condition8%Asset age and data freshness — older vintages and stale monitoring data attract discounts

Total: 100%


Composite Score Calculation​

Score = (TechnicalQuality × 0.25)
+ (Additionality × 0.20)
+ (Permanence × 0.20)
+ (CertificationLvl × 0.15)
+ (SocialImpact × 0.12)
+ (VintageCondition × 0.08)

Each dimension is scored 0–100 by the Oracle API based on the parameters submitted with the certificate. The composite score is also 0–100.


Rating Bands​

The composite score maps to one of five rating bands:

BandScore RangeDescription
AAA85–100Highest integrity — premium pricing
AA75–84High quality
A65–74Good quality
BBB50–64Minimum eligible — compliance-grade pricing
Not Eligible< 50Below threshold — cannot be tokenized on NCRB

The minimum score for tokenization is 50 (BBB).


Sub-Type Scoring Bonuses​

When a certificate's subType field (stored in assetMetadata) maps to a known sub-type with affectsScoring: true, bonus points are added to the raw dimension scores before the composite is calculated. Available sub-types are served by GET /api/registry-standards/sub-types?asset_type_code={id}.

Carbon credits (assetType 0):

Sub-typeAdditionality bonusCo-benefits bonus
compliance+3—
removal_dac+5+3
removal_beccs+4+2
removal_enhanced_weathering+3—

Other asset types:

AssetSub-typeDimensionBonus
Plasticocean_boundCo-benefits+4
Nitrogennitrous_oxideAdditionality+3
AgriculturalregenerativeAdditionality+3
PhosphoruswatershedCo-benefits+3
Waterenvironmental_flowCo-benefits+4
MiningreclaimedCo-benefits+4
Forestrynatural_forest, agroforestryCo-benefits+3
BiodiversitywetlandCo-benefits+4
Biodiversitycoastal_marineCo-benefits+3

Paris Agreement Article 6.4 Bonuses​

For carbon credits (assetType 0), three fields in assetMetadata trigger additional additionality bonuses. These are set during asset registration and stored as part of the on-chain assetMetadata JSON.

FieldValueAdditionality bonus
creditMechanismarticle_6_4+5
creditMechanismcorsia+3
correspondingAdjustmentapplied+2
correspondingAdjustment + loaStatusapplied + provided+1 (stacked on top of the CA bonus)

creditMechanism values:

ValueDescription
vcmVoluntary Carbon Market (no bonus)
article_6_4UN Paris Agreement Article 6.4 mechanism
corsiaICAO CORSIA aviation offsetting
cdm_transitionCDM credits transitioning to Article 6.4

correspondingAdjustment — applied means the host country has formally transferred the mitigation outcome to the buyer's NDC, preventing double-counting. This is the key integrity requirement for Article 6.4 compliance.

loaStatus — provided means a Letter of Authorisation from the host country government is on file.


SDG Co-Benefits Bonus​

For all asset types, each UN SDG goal listed in sdgGoals adds +1 to the co-benefits dimension score, capped at +4. This bonus stacks on top of any sub-type co-benefits bonus.

SDG goals alignedCo-benefits bonus
0+0
1+1
2+2
3+3
4 or more+4 (cap)

SDG goals are stored as an integer array in assetMetadata.sdgGoals (e.g. [13, 14, 15]).


Social Impact Premium​

The Social Impact dimension (12%) reflects co-benefits that command price premiums from institutional buyers. Corporate buyers including Microsoft, Google, and Meta explicitly require social impact verification in procurement criteria.

Co-benefitTypical Price Premium
CCB Gold certification+30–50%
SDG alignment (3+ goals)+20–40%
Indigenous community engagement+40–100%
Community employment > 50 FTE+20–30%

These premiums are applied on top of the base band price range.


Asset-Specific Technical Quality Criteria​

The Technical Quality dimension (25%) is the most asset-specific. Here is how it is applied per asset class:

Asset ClassTechnical Quality Criteria
Carbon CreditsSylvera / BeZero rating (minimum BBB); vintage within 5 years; third-party verification
Plastic CreditsCollection type (ocean-bound > landfill > recycling); geographic provenance tracking
Nitrogen CreditsDelivery ratio (0–1.0) — fraction of upstream reduction reaching the regulated water body
Phosphorus CreditsDelivery ratio (0–1.0) — phosphorus binds to sediment, transport dynamics differ from nitrogen
Agricultural LandUSDA Land Capability Classification: Class I (prime) → Class IV (limited); LESA score
Mining RightsReserve classification (NI 43-101 / JORC / S-K 1300); ore grade (g/t or equivalent)
Water RightsPriority date seniority (senior > intermediate > junior); use type (municipal > industrial > agricultural)
Renewable Energy CreditsSource type; registry tier (APX, WREGIS, M-RETS); state compliance class (Class I > voluntary)
Forestry RightsNHLA timber grade (FAS > No. 1 Common); FSC/SFI/ATFS certification level
Biodiversity CreditsUK Biodiversity Metric 4.0 distinctiveness (D6 Very High → D3 Medium minimum); NatureQuant index

On-Chain Storage​

After the Oracle API computes the score, it writes it to the QualityAssessment contract:

Oracle API computes score
│
▼
Oracle API calls QualityAssessment.recordAssessment(serialNumber, score, dimensions)
│
▼
Score stored on-chain — immutable and auditable
│
▼
ncrb-indexer reads QualityAssessment events
│
▼
Score available via GET /api/quality-profiles/score/:serialNumber

Reading the Methodology​

The current dimension weights and band thresholds for any asset type can be queried at runtime:

# Quality profile (dimensions + weights)
GET /api/quality-profiles/0 # assetType 0 = Carbon Credits

# Rating bands (score ranges + price multipliers)
GET /api/quality-profiles/0/bands

# Full methodology rules
GET /api/quality/methodology

The weights stored on-chain in QualityAssessment are the authoritative source. The database-side registry standards (/api/registry-standards/quality-parameters/:registryId/:assetTypeId) provide the registry-specific parameter definitions used as inputs.


Example: Assessing a Carbon Credit​

Quality assessment is triggered automatically when the Oracle processes a CertificateSubmitted event. The certificate's assetMetadata JSON (stored on-chain) provides the inputs.

Example assetMetadata for a high-scoring Article 6.4 carbon credit:

{
"methodology": "VM0015",
"vintage": 2023,
"subType": "removal_dac",
"creditMechanism": "article_6_4",
"correspondingAdjustment": "applied",
"loaStatus": "provided",
"sdgGoals": [7, 13, 14, 15],
"projectName": "Bangladesh Mangrove Reforestation",
"country": "BD"
}

Scoring result for this certificate:

DimensionBase scoreBonusFinal
Technical Quality——~80
Additionality~60+5 (Art. 6.4) +2 (CA) +1 (LoA) = +8~68
Co-benefits~60+3 (removal_dac sub-type) +4 (4 SDGs) = +7~67
Certification Level——~75
Social Impact——~80
Vintage/Condition——~72

Bonus points are added to the raw dimension score (capped at 100 per dimension) before the weighted composite is calculated.